Compression Molding vs Injection Molding - How to choose the right technology for your part? | IN3DTEC | Prototyping & On-demand manufacturing services

Molding vs Injection Molding How to choose the right technology for your part?

The step-by-step compression molding process works as follows:

STEP 1:Create molds
Tooling can be produced in a number of ways, including machining, die casting, 3D printing.

STEP 2:Set up the machine
Depending on the specific machine or device you’re using, this may include cleaning the mold, turning on the heat, and other set-up processes.

STEP 3:Prepare charge
Selected the type of material you want to use and determine the proper amount of material. If your charge is too big, excess material will seep out of the mold and result in flash that you will need to manually cut off.

STEP 4:Insert charge
Place the charge in the center of the bottom mold.

STEP 5:Compress part
Close the top mold, apply pressure, and wait for your piece to form. Many manufacturers also use heat during the compression process, which softens the raw materials and can help speed up production.

STEP 6:Release part
Remove the finished piece.

STEP 7:Clean part
Resin flash around the edges must be manually cut off or removed, and the part may need to be cleaned before the final assembly.

The step-by-step injection molding process works as follows:

STEP 1: The mold closes
The Injection Molding cycle timer begins when the mold closes.

STEP 2: Injection
The heated plastic is injected into the mold. As the melt enters the mold, the displaced air escapes through vents in the injection pins and along the parting line. Runner, gate and vent design are important to insure the mold is properly filled.

STEP 3: Cooling
Once the mold is filled the part is allowed to cool for the exact amount of time needed to harden the material. Cooling time is dependent on the type of resin used and the thickness of the part. Each mold is designed with internal cooling or heating lines where water is cycled through the mold to maintain a constant temperature.

STEP 4: Plasticizing the resin
While the part cools, the barrel screw retracts and draws new plastic resin into the barrel from the material hopper. The heater bands maintain the needed barrel temperature for the type of resin being used.

STEP 5: Ejection
The mold opens and the ejector rod moves the ejector pins forward.
The part falls and is captured in a bin located below the mold.

Compression Molding vs. Injection Molding

Compression molding and injection molding are very similar, but they have one major difference. In compression molding, molds are closed around the charge, and in injection molding, the charge is injected into a closed mold cavity.

Today’s manufacturers frequently use both compression and injection molding but for different types of parts. Injection molding is typically a better choice for more complex parts. It can be performed with a variety of materials, most commonly thermoplastic polymers. While compression molding is a great option for relatively simple designs, including ultra-large basic shapes that cannot be produced using extrusion techniques.For basic plastic parts made with thermoset materials, compression moulding remains a popular technique, especially for gaskets, seals, and grommets.

Injection molding requires a shorter cycle time than compression molding, so it’s often faster and more cost-effective if you need to produce a large number of parts. However, compression molding is a lower-pressure production method, so the tooling costs are often lower. It also wastes little material, providing an advantage when working with expensive materials.

As a general rule of thumb, high volume production is better suited for injection molding, while compression molding is used rather for low and medium series of part production.